Tuesday, October 18, 2011

Giving Voice to Values – ethical education for business students - By Paul Wedel

If business schools are teaching ethics, why are there so many business scandals and why are the culprits so often MBAs? These questions troubled Dr. Mary Gentile, a teacher of business ethics now a professor and researcher at Babson College. They were questions, she said, that had caused a crisis of despair in her own professional life.
But they were questions that sparked her to begin research into the ethical dilemmas faced by business people and the failure of traditional teaching to prepare them for those dilemmas. The result of that research has led to a new approach to teaching ethics she calls “Giving Voice to Values (GVV).”
Dr. Gentile, speaking at a workshop at the Asian Forum on CSR (AFCSR) in Manila, said that traditional teaching focuses on awareness of ethical situations, often through case studies, and analysis of ethical reasoning, often based on traditional philosophical approaches to ethics.
Although both awareness and analysis were needed, she said, they were insufficient to make much change in the way business was conducted in the real world outside of the classroom.
“We needed to shift from the question of what you should do to be ethical to how do you get it done, from moral judgment to implementation,” Dr. Gentile said. She said the practical questions of how to act in ethically challenging situations were the focus of the GVV teaching curriculum and materials. Instead of ending a case with deciding what would be the right thing to do, the GVV cases challenge the students to figure how to do it effectively – “what should be said to whom, what data should be collected, how to push back against unethical actions, how to create coalitions, how to voice action on ethical conduct,” she said.
This approach not only gave students the tools with which to deal with ethically difficult situations but also challenged the brightest students to use their knowledge of business and human behavior to come up with innovative ways to take action on ethics, she said.
“We are not trying to change people, but to help them do the things they already want to do,” she said.
The GVV approach gives students the tools, the practices, the coaching and most importantly, the rehearsal of ways to implement ethical behavior in difficult situations, Dr. Gentile said.
She said her work at Babson has begun to help large corporations, including a major US defense contractor, to use the GVV approach in their internal staff development training and that the feedback has been encouraging.
“We are showing them that taking effective ethical action is just another part of doing business – you have to be strategic and smart about it because ethical issues are not a special case, they are a regular part of business decision-making,” she said.
Dr. Gentile said that the GVV curriculum and materials were available free online to anyone interested in using them at http://www.babson.edu/faculty/teaching-learning/gvv/Pages/home.aspx
She said that while there may be differences in values between different cultures, there were some “hyper norms” that apply in all countries. In any case, she said, the approach starts with the students own values and concentrates on teaching them to put those into effective action within a company.
Dr. Gentile said that more data across cultures was being gathered by professors using it in countries such as India, China and Ghana and that this learning was being used to further develop the materials and cases available on line.
You can see videos of Dr. Gentile talking about the GVV curriculum here and here.

Monday, October 17, 2011

The Global Learning Village – a public-private partnership for community education in Australia – By Paul Wedel

The first plenary session of the Asian Forum on CSR (AFCSR) presented an example of cooperation among corporations, government and community organizations to improve education and employability in a once neglected suburb of Melbourne, Australia.

Frank McGuire, the member of Parliament for the area called Broadmeadows, said this cooperation, dubbed the “Global Learning Village” has made a major impact by creating using communications technology to provide widely available online learning programs.

McGuire said the core philosophy was “each child must be globally connected.”

He said the project had to work through typical obstacles of government – the silo mentality, institutional egos, and bureaucratic inertia. He described how corporate buy-in gave credibility to the project along with financial resources and management expertise.

They key to getting corporate buy-in, he said, was creating projects that were a “good value fit” with corporate brands. He cited the examples of the local newspaper financing a community library and ICT companies including Microsoft, Intel and CISCO getting behind the rollout of a high-speed broadband network and an “ideas lab” that will provide the basis for future development of community learning.

The Global Learning village, he said, had helped make Broadmeadows a more prosperous community and a key driver of economic growth in Victoria.

In response to a question, McGuire said he was developing a handbook to developing such projects elsewhere that he called “Global Learning Village in a Box.” Those interested could contact him at Frank@GLV.org.au for details.

Participants at the opening session of the AFCSR

This was followed by a presentation by Edita A. de Leon, senior vice president for Nestle (Philippines), who described what she called “creating shared value.” She presented this as a new twist to CSR introduced by Harvard professor Michael Porter.

In fact, however, shared value has always been a key element of effective corporate social responsibility program. Without benefit to both society and the company any program claiming to be CSR would be short-lived and ineffective. K.I.Asia has taught this “strategic CSR” for nearly a decade in its CSR training program for corporate executives.

Ms. De Leon correctly noted that effective CSR programs that are strategically aligned with corporate business interests are likely to be continued even through market downturns and financial crises. “They cannot be cut because they are integral to the sustainability of the company.”

She cited three ways to increase shared value:

  • Developing new products, markets or value propositions that provide social benefits along with a financial return to the company.
  • Dealing with social or environmental issues that cause problems in the company value chain, such as workers ill-prepared for high-tech employment, inadequate water supplies or unhappy employees
  • Creating “community cluster” in which suppliers, service providers, government agencies, community organizations, educational institutions and corporations work together to “drive competitiveness.

She said Nestle programs were examples of creating shared value and described efforts to improve farm productivity and extend the Nestle supply chain to reach small community stores at the so-called “bottom of the pyramid” by hiring motorcycle deliverymen.

Ms. De Leon said the closer the program was to the company’s core activities the more likely it was to get significant funding and corporate attention.

In conclusion, she said that a crucial element of such shared value CSR programs was to be able to measure their impact on both society and the company.

The Asian Forum on CSR – improving the ways that companies contribute to sustainable development - By Paul Wedel

This week I will be attending the annual Asian Forum on Corporate Responsibility (AFCSR) in the Philippines and will be blogging on the talks, workshops and discussions at the forum. This is the 10th year that the AFCSR has brought together leading thinkers on AFCSR from the corporate, government, academic and non-profit sectors in Asia. 

The theme this year is “Strategic CSR: Creating Shared Value” – promoting the key idea that CSR is not something additional to regular business, not something done for short-term PR value, but is an integral part of the long-term corporate business strategy. The forum this year will have five core topics:

  • Assessment of the firm – its internal culture, objectives and capabilities – and the external environment – government regulation, public perception and industry structure
  • Implementation of CSR – focused on the ways that companies best carry out activities connected with its environmental and social responsibilities
  • Monitoring and evaluation – looking at ways that companies track and evaluate their CSR activities for accurate reporting and continual improvement
  • Embedding CSR within the corporation – making it a permanent and integral part of the company’s approach to business
  • Moving forward – learning from past experience to improve CSR performance in the future

These topics will be covered in a two-day series of plenary speeches, small group workshops, panel discussions and debates. I will blog on the highlights of the sessions that I attend as well as the presentation I will make on CSR partnering among corporations, government agencies and non-profits.
Another key part of the annual forum is the Asian CSR Awards Program that recognizes Asian companies for outstanding, innovative and world-class CSR services, projects and programs. Awards will be given in four areas of social responsibility:
  • Poverty Alleviation
  • Health Enhancement
  • Environmental Excellence
  • Education Improvement
As one of the judges for the Poverty Alleviation award, I reviewed a large number of corporate programs that indicate growing integration of company strategy with CSR. Many of these programs made clear and significant contributions to employment and income for poor people. It will be interesting to see which companies win the other awards and whether there has been progress in the development of CSR programs on health, environment and education.

Monday, September 26, 2011

Thailand ready to change its SME support policies --- by Paul Wedel

The Thai government is rightly worried about the ability of small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) to survive the growing competitive challenges they face. Rising labor costs, fast-changing technology, free trade agreements and the globalization of markets mean that many small companies will be hard-pressed to survive the next five years.

Since SMEs make up more than 99% of all enterprises in this country, employ 78% of the workforce and generate 43% of non-agricultural GDP, these changes pose a challenge to the entire Thai economy.

Difficulties in meeting this challenge led the Thai government to become the first in Southeast Asia to invite the Organization for Economic Cooperation and Development (OECD) to review its SME and entrepreneurship policies. Earlier this month the Office of SME Promotion (OSMEP) conducted a seminar and brainstorming session with senior government officials, and in recognition of K.I.Asia’s long experience in assisting SME development, I was invited to participate as moderator for the discussion.

Mr. Pak Tongsom, the deputy director-general of OSMEP, said the policy review showed that urgent changes were needed.

“There is no time to waste in making the policy changes needed to help our entrepreneurs with the funding, skills and knowledge to overcome the challenges and seize the opportunities confronting them,” he said in opening the seminar.

Dr. Jonathan Potter, the senior economist in the OECD Centre for Entrepreneurship, Small and Medium-sized Enterprises and Local Development who headed the policy review, said his team had identified a number of weaknesses. These included a lack of policy coherence among the many government agencies dealing with SMEs, failure to develop enough middle-sized enterprises, lack of technological readiness, inflexible financing for SMEs and a business environment burdened with unnecessary red tape and corruption.

For anyone working in the Thai SME sector, these findings revealed no surprises.

The tendency of government agencies to work in silos, often competing with one another for budget, is a common problem. The OECD team recommended reinforcing the role of OSMEP as the central body for SME and entrepreneurship policy formulation and coordination. This is a good idea, but I expect it will take a strong stand at the cabinet level to induce powerful ministries such as Industry and Commerce to cede their policy leadership roles to OSMEP. Sharing and improving the various SME statistics and databases maintained by different agencies are also needed to provide better management information for policy implementation.

Dr. Potter said policy implementation could be improved by moving to flexible, rolling program budgeting, away from the current system of fixed annual budgets. He also called for independent, results-based evaluation of all projects and programs in order to pull funding from ineffective activities.

Technological readiness is another difficulty. Dr. Potter told the seminar that although Thailand has a high rate of entrepreneurship, some 30% of Thai entrepreneurs were forced into business out of necessity, rather than because they had a new technology or a great business opportunity. This compares with developed economies where, on average, only 4% of entrepreneurs are in business because they have no other choice. Dr. Potter warned that Thailand’s high proportion of “necessity SMEs” means they will have difficult competing in a crowded low-tech market, leading to slow growth and poor employment conditions.

The OECD team recommended that government support focus more on technology-driven SMEs with the capabilities to grow quickly into medium-sized enterprises, as these companies could provide a much bigger boost to the economy. Research has shown that as few as 6% of a nation’s companies can be responsible for 90% of new job creation.

OSMEP agreed. “Even giants are born small,” Pak said. “We need effective policies and sufficient nurturing to help our baby giants grow to their full potential.”

The OECD recommended the creation of an "SME Toolkit" website similar to one used in Singapore that would provide information and software to help SMEs with issues such as accounting, finance, business planning, marketing and technology.

The officials at the seminar said that the findings of the OECD policy review were already being incorporated into the country’s Third SME Promotion Master Plan (2012-1016), due to go into effect shortly.

If that plan and the proposed policy improvements win approval and strong support from the government, Thai SMEs will be in a better position to compete in the challenging decade ahead.

Thursday, July 28, 2011

“One tablet per child” – hardware is hardly enough By Paul Wedel

 The work of K.I.Asia in helping Thai schools make better use of IT has taught us that far more important than any hardware is the software provided with it and the management that supports it. If tablets are to be really useful in Thai schools, much work needs to be done before the goodies are handed out.

Thai teachers in K.I.Asia’s One Computer Classroom program, now supported by Boeing, learn how to incorporate video into their teaching and how to encourage students to use the computer in group learning projects.

.Here is my list of the ten most important steps to take before 800,000 tablets are bought and distributed to Thai schools.

 1.     Study the research on use of laptops elsewhere in the world as well as Thailand’s own experience in using computers in the classroom

2.     Decide which parts of the Thai curriculum, for each subject, at each grade level, are best taught using the tablet and which are best taught by other methods

3.     Develop specific teaching methodologies and lesson plans that will enable teachers to make effective use of the devices for those parts of the curriculum

4.     Digitize existing textbooks and load them onto the tablets

5.     Identify, review and select available teaching software for the tablets, encouraging development of Thai-specific learning software, if necessary, and load the software onto the tablets

6.     Identify additional reading for the advanced student and the slow learner for each subject at each level, digitize it and load it onto the tablets

7.     Launch a pilot program in at least 100 schools to test the devices, teaching methodologies, support systems and digitized materials. Small, poor and rural schools should be the focus of the pilots because everything that works in these schools will probably work even better in the larger, richer schools.

8.     Train pilot school teachers in the tablet methodologies, software and materials

9.     Train pilot school administrators on the best ways to manage, technically support and evaluate teaching with the tablets

10.  Evaluate the experience of the pilot schools and adjust materials, methodologies, software, technical support systems and management accordingly and roll out to other schools in a systematic way

Clearly, there is much work to do to convert a catchy campaign promise into a viable educational program, but it doesn’t have to take years. A pilot program could begin in 2012 and a phased roll-out started a year later. Success or failure will depend on how well the program is planned and implemented, not on which hardware is bought or how quickly it is handed out.

These are my thoughts. I look forward to hearing your thoughts on how best to introduce tablet computers to Thai schools so they can help make a real and much-needed improvement in learning.


Monday, July 25, 2011

How do tablets help learning? – Let me count the ways by Paul Wedel

The campaign pledge of the Pheu Thai Party to provide primary school students with tablet computers has stirred considerable controversy, with critics abounding.

Dr. Olarn Chaipravat, chief economic strategist of the party, insists the new government will go ahead with its promise to provide Android tablet computers to 800,000 to 1 million middle-school children nationwide in 2012.  Party officials say the primary school computer handout will be followed by distribution of more powerful devices to students in the higher grades. Dr. Olarn says the program is “aimed at solving the issue of the lack of skills in both foreign languages and mathematics among our children" – undoubtedly a good objective.

Five Reasons Why Students Should Use a Tablet PC



K.I.Asia’s yearsof experience in the use of computers in Thai schools and recent research in other countries indicate that tablets can help. Let me list the ways:
•       An intuitive interface and the use of an electronic pen make tablets easy for even very young students to use
•      Tablets help students organize notes, presentations and texts for more efficient learning

•       Journal diagrams can easily be drawn, annotated and shared
•       Teachers can mark, comment on and return students’ electronic documents more efficiently
•       Pupils find tablet computers fun to use, so they are motivated to do school work on them
•       Working in groups is more efficient because work files can be easily shared
•       Easy wireless links allow in-school communication as well as access to the Internet.
•       Tablets can be used both in school and at home
•       Tablets eliminate the need for a “computer room” filled with desktop PCs where little subject learning takes place
•       Books can be read on screen, replacing heavy paper books and cutting costs for printing and distributing them
•       Assignment dates can be transmitted to tablets, reminding children of work due
•       Educational videos and other visual materials can be used that research shows enable children to learn more effectively
•       Numerous “learning apps” are available and the number is growing
•       Children can learn at their own pace with materials based on individual learning needs
•        “Parent Portals” can be set up that allow parents to see their children’s schedules, teacher contact information, grades and information on helping their children learn

To reduce concerns about access to inappropriate web sites, technology such as the “Kineo” tablet could be used. This allows school officials to control the books and lessons that appear on each student's Kineo. Another possibility is “SafeStart,” a controlled interface that allows children to access only approved applications and websites.
There are, of course, some downsides to use of tablets in schools. These include:
•       High initial cost that takes money away from other important needs like better salaries for teachers
•       Time needed for initial set-up, including the loading of appropriate content
•       Need for good technical support and fast wireless access
•       Short battery life that may require in-school re-charging
•       Low screen illumination
•       Electronic pens are easily lost
•       Wireless networks can be slow, frustrating downloads of some media

 The latest tablets, however, have been improved to deal with some of the technical problems cited in earlier studies at much lower costs. But hardware selection is not the critical issue.

 A recent study published in the Journal of Research on Technology in Education focused on the use of tablets for children aged three to six. It concluded that there was high child interest and quick learning on the tablets. “Although technical issues in learning this new technology were encountered, children were interested and persisted without frustration,” the authors wrote. “What seems to matter for children’s learning is the ways teachers choose to implement this technology.”

 Although international experience with tablets in the classroom has generally been positive, how best should the devices be introduced and managed in Thailand?  In my next blog I will suggest the ten things that should be done before the new Thai government distributes tablet computers to schools. In the meantime, I welcome your comments.